Minnesota is set to wave goodbye to its old state flag, long considered offensive by many Native Americans, as a special commission unveils a brand-new design featuring a striking eight-pointed North Star against a dark blue background shaped like the state. The State Emblems Redesign Commission made this historic decision on Tuesday, opting for a design that aims to be inclusive and representative of all Minnesotans.
Symbolism and Simplicity Triumph
The chosen design is a result of careful deliberation and consideration of various elements. The eight-pointed North Star pays homage to Minnesota’s state motto, the “Star of the North.” The dark blue background, shaped like the state itself, is complemented by a solid light blue field at the right, representing the Mississippi River, considered by some as the most significant river in the United States. The commission, led by Chairman Luis Fitch, emphasized symmetry and simplicity, choosing a design that can resonate with a diverse population.
Creator’s Gratitude and Hope for Unity
The new flag is a revision of a design submitted by 24-year-old Andrew Prekker from Luverne. In a statement read to the commission, Prekker expressed his gratitude for the “rare privilege” of contributing to state history. He hopes that the new flag will bring unity and pride to Minnesota, representing all its people, including Indigenous communities and tribal nations historically excluded from the narrative. The design aims to foster a sense of pride and honor for every Minnesotan, regardless of background.
Out With the Old: Critique of Minnesota Current Flag
Minnesota’s current flag, dating back to 1957, has faced criticism for its outdated and offensive imagery. The depiction of a Native American riding off into the sunset while a white settler plows his field with a rifle nearby has been viewed as suggesting the defeat of Indigenous people and the triumph of white settlers. The 11 recognized Dakota and Ojibwe tribes found the previous design offensive, leading to the push for a more inclusive and culturally sensitive symbol.
Moving Forward: Potential Hurdles and Unresolved Concerns
While the new flag and seal are set to become official on April 1, 2024, some challenges lie ahead. Two Republican nonvoting members of the commission, Rep. Bjorn Olson and Sen. Steve Drazkowski, plan to submit a minority report to the Legislature. They argue that the chosen seal violates the statute that created the commission, as it should select a unifying symbol. With the inclusion of the Dakota name on the seal, concerns are raised about potentially favoring one race over others. The process is criticized for being rushed, with calls for Minnesotans to vote on both the flag and seal next November.
Minnesota’s decision to replace its old state flag with a design that embraces inclusivity and simplicity is a significant step towards creating a symbol that all residents can rally behind. The symbolism behind the new flag reflects the state’s motto and geographical significance, while the emphasis on simplicity aligns with the principles of good flag design. However, as the transition unfolds, the potential for challenges and disagreements underscores the complexities of creating symbols that truly represent the diverse and evolving identity of a state.